There are three kinds of bait to find: fish eggs, oysters, and glowing worms. You must offer the MerLeader each kind. The fish eggs will stay in your inventory for a while, but the oyster will disappear before you crack it open, and the glowing worms will disappear once you retrieve the summoning fish artifact, so be sure to offer those to the MerLeader before doing anything else with them.

At the start of the chapter, highlight "Main Mast". Select it four times.

In the jungle on Spoon Isle, you will find a Fishing Well. To find the Fishing Well, from the entrance (where the pirates are aruging) go up, then right. On the Fishing Well is a coupon for fish eggs on it. Take the coupon back to the bait shop to trade for the fish eggs, then return to the Fishing Well in the jungle. Combine the hook and fish eggs in your inventory, and Guybrush will go fishing. He gets nothing useful, but you get this trophy.

Use the hook in your inventory on the following people at the following times:

• Morgan LeFay: At the start of the chapter. Use the hook on her in between picking it up and throwing her off your ship.
• Hardtack: After the blockade has moved in, get on the raft and go to the blockade in the southeast (next to the "Jerkbait Islands" label). You must do this before you set up his distraction, because once he is distracted you cannot select him.
• Pox-Ridden Pirates: Also after the blockade has moved in. You will find them harassing LeChuck in the jungle. Make sure to threaten them before getting rid of them.
• McGillicutty: After you slip past the blockade and travel to his ship. Stand to the left of the cannon so you can select him easily. Be sure to do this before you sink his ship.

After saving the MerLeader from McGillicuty and unlocking "Mighty Merperson Rescuer", you will find yourself in a dialog with the MerLeader. Choose "What's the secret of Monkey Island?". You will need to do this before selecting the option about La Esponja Grande, or you will lose your chance.

This trophy is story related and cannot be missed. If you get stuck, see "The BIG Finish".

As part of the story, you will aqcuire a book called "101 Fish Jokes". Simply look at the book from your inventory ( on the book when in the inventory), and the open book will display on screen with a joke for you to read. Close the book with , and then repeat. Once you have read them all, the trophy will unlock. Thankfully, despite the book's title, there are only 14 jokes you need to read.

When you find LeChuck on the cliff, talk to him and choose these dialog options:

• So, how much longer do you think?
• What are you carrying with you?
• Use...
• ...claw thingie...
• ...yourself.

This trophy is story related and cannot be missed. Should you find yourself stuck somewhere, refer to this excellent spoiler-free walkthrough from Lostsaint18: Tales of MI: Chapter 2 Walkthrough - PS3Trophies.org