Like AMVs, can you tell me what you think of my Deadman Wonderland AMV.

[ImDale]

Basically i just got into editing and i'd like to start editing much more variety of things such as games, animes and such, but in order to do that i need constructive criticism on my projects.

On Youtube, people only view the video not comment, as this is my second AMV i'd like people to give me that criticism i need so i can further improve my projects.

This is my second AMV:

Deadman Wonderland - AMV - Sore Winner - YouTube

Deadman Wonderland - AMV - Sore Winner - YouTube

I have a first one on my computer but when i upload it to youtube it gets removed or blocked in countries which is rather annoying.

Thanks.

I also would like things that are wrong with my AMV's as well, don't afraid to be harsh

[sunnygrg]

It's great actually but why the 480p resolution videos? There are good 720p raws out if you search on Nyaa. Next time do consider that if you have a PC that has the horsepower.

[ImDale]

Originally Posted by sunnygrg

It's great actually but why the 480p resolution videos? There are good 720p raws out if you search on Nyaa. Next time do consider that if you have a PC that has the horsepower.

I just rendered it as a DVD quality i think since my Laptop isn't very good.

Here's the settings of the rendering quality:



Can you recommend which one i should use? (1280*720)?

Also thanks for the "great" comment, made me more eager to make AMV's

[darkdante14]

I can't see the image in your comment. Try putting direct link between those [IMG] codes.

This is the direct link - http://img14.imageshack.us/img14/7099/unledvxr.png

Spoiler! (click here to reveal)

As for AMV, your editing is good and you have a lot of patience but allow me to warn you. People are lazy, meaning, 3 and a half minutes may be a bit too long for someone if you don't have cool effects in your vid. Regardless, great editing and I liked the song but 1 thing bothered me.

Song (or rather audio) seemed a bit low-quality and when I took a look at your settings I understood why. Did you really render audio at 64 kbps? Standard quality for songs is about 180 or rather 192 kbps. One of the best song quality is 320 kbps. 320 is pure gold for my ears. Even if you render HD video but put audio at 192kbps, the quality of song will be standard even when watched in HD. I learned that in hard way by uploading an HD video, but song sounded like crap Then again you do have to know what quality of song do have yourself. There's no point to render audio at 320 kbs when I have a song that only has the quality of 192.

Anyway, great video especially for your second AMV. A lot better than my failed AMV attempts

[ImDale]

Hehe, would quote but it's rather long , thanks for the great comment, yeah i rendered as 64 Kbps, i saw a guide which said render at a higher Kbps but since it was DVD quality rendering, i didn't bother making the sound high quality, i'll keep that in mind next time i render.

Also about the image, i was 100% sure i put the direct link between the [IMG], guess not

[darkdante14]

Originally Posted by ImDale

Also about the image, i was 100% sure i put the direct link between the [IMG], guess not

You put a link to the image but not the direct link I use imageshack myself