Handyman Carnby = stupid!

[Long3n]

Got the platinum now. I had to use this following guide to help me in order to get this crazy Handyman Carnby.

Handyman Carnby Achievement Guide(s) - Xbox360Achievements.org

[Xernova]

I know this is a bit late, but there's one thing that is worth noting about this evil trophy. I don't think it has been mentioned here yet (unless I overlooked it), but in my case I'm pretty sure the trophy glitched out.

I followed a list of all combinations, making sure not to miss a single combo. No trophy unlocked... I tried it again 2 more times... still nothing. Then I gave up for a while, until I thought of something: I had already finished the game before the trophy patch had been released. So I figured, maybe the trophy didn't unlock because I (obviously) made several combos before the patch added the trophies and the game doesn't count those anymore?

So I decided to delete my savedata and start the game from scratch. I followed the same list of combinations again and this time... trophy unlocked on the 1st try! I can't say with 100% certainty that the trophy glitched out because of the reason I gave above, but I wouldn't know what else it could have been. I'm just throwing this out here, just in case anyone else runs into the same problem again... :S

[Icerunner45]

I just got the Handyman Carnby trophy on Chapter 8 while playing through the game. I found it to be pretty easy. I just followed the trophy guide and it was a breeze.

[Codine]

The only one I missed out on was transfering the liquid to another bottle, got it easy enough though.

[SinEater]

Originally Posted by Codine

The only one I missed out on was transfering the liquid to another bottle, got it easy enough though.

Yup that one just got me too, I had done everything at least 3 times...