Nurture or Nature? 
Complete "Remember My Family".
Though it's not an actual story mission it is a mission that is unlocked after the games completion. Go to Blackwater and by the train station is a stranger. Talk to him and finish the mission and you will get the trophy.
What About Hand Grenades? 
Get a ringer in a game of Horseshoes.
This is another trophy that requires some luck and patience. Horseshoes can be found in towns and small settlements throughout the world but the easiest one to get to is the one on the MacFarlane Farm. The Horseshoe pit will be located behind your house on the farm. Bet the lowest amount you can so that it will be easier for you. Use
to zoom in and make sure that your middle finger is lined up exactly on the post. Now is where you will need a little luck. Move the
so that you can get power behind your throw. Move it all the way down and quickly move the
back up. Release the horseshoe at the middle line. If you timed it all right and you aimed correctly you should at least hit the post. Continue using this method until you get your ringer. Below is a video showing the strategy to get the trophy. Thanks to
RoosterTeeth for the video
Fightin' Around the World
Knock someone out in melee in every saloon in the game in Single Player.
There are 7 total saloons throughout the world. You will need to have West Elizabeth unlocked to get this trophy as the final saloon is located there. Once you enter a saloon make sure you have your fists out by checking your weapon radial, then punch someone in the saloon by locking on with
and punching with
. Block his punches with
and quickly counter him with punches of your own. After you land a combo of punches try to tackle him to the ground by pushing
. This will make it easier as you get to take free hits on him. Continue to punch him until he's knocked out. Be ready for a fight though as the people in the saloon won't like your behavior. I suggest you get out of the saloon as quick as possible and ride away. The locations as well as a map for the saloons are below:
New Austin
1. Armadillo
2. RathSkeller Fork
3. Thieves' Landing
Nuevo Paraiso
4. Escalera
5. Chuparosa
6. Casa Madrugada
West Elizabeth
7. Blackwater
Map Locations
Strange Things are Afoot
Complete a task for Stranger.
See
People are Still Strange
People are Still Strange 
Complete 15 tasks for Strangers.
The Strangers are represented by a question mark on the map. Go to it and talk to the person there to start the mission. These missions can be done at any time. Below is a map and a written out locations list for the strangers. Thanks to
tima_13 for the complete locations list.
Spoiler! (click here to reveal)
|
1. American Lobbyist
Required Mission: "An Appointed Time"
First Location: "Blackwater"
2. Remember My Family
Required Mission: "The Last Enemy That Shall be Destroyed"
First Location: "Blackwater"
3. The Wronged Woman
Required Mission: "An Appointed Time"
First Location: "Blackwater"
4. The Prohibitionist
Required Mission: "An Appointed Time" & #3 "The Wronged Woman"
First Location: "Blackwater"
5. Aztec Gold
Required Mission: "Must a Savior Die?"
First Location: "Sidewinder Gulch"
6. Poppycock
Required Mission: "Civilization, at Any Price"
First Location: "Chuparosa"
7. Love is the Opiate
Required Mission: "Empty Promises" & #6 "Poppycock"
First Location: "El Matadero"
8. Eva in Peril
Required Mission: "Lucky in Love"
First Location: "Casa Madrugada"
9. Deadalus and Son
Required Mission: "We shall be Together in Paradise"
First Location: "Agave Viejo"
*************
#10 doesn't count towards 100%, because apparently if you don't do all parts
of this mission before the main story ends, then you can't do it
*************
10. I Know You
Required Mission: "A tempest Looms"
First Location: "Mescalero"
-------
Required Mission: "We Shall be together in paradise"
Second Location: "Mescalero"
-------
Required Mission: "An Appointed Time"
Third Location: "Mescalero"
11. Lights Camera Action
Required Mission: "The Sport of Kings and Liars"
First Location: "Armadillo"
-------
Required Mission: "An Appointed Time"
Second Location: "Pacific Union Railroad Camp"
12. Who are you to Judge
Required Mission: "Liars, Cheats and Other Proud Americans"
First Location: "Rathskeller Fork"
13. Water and Honesty
Required Mission: "Political Realities in Armadillo"
First Location: between "Armadillo and MacFarlane's Ranch"
14. Jenny's Faith
Required Mission: "This is Armadillo USA"
First Location: "Ridgewood Farm"
15. Flowers for a lady
Required Mission: "New Friends, Old Problems"
First Location: between "MacFarlane's Ranch and Thieve's Landing"
16. Let No Man Put Asunder
Required Mission: "Obstacles in Our Path"
First Location: Coot's Chapel
17. California
Required Mission: "Women and Cattle"
First Location: "Gaptooth Ridge"
-------
Required Mission: none; 1 or 2 days in game
Second Location: "Cueva Seca"
-------
Required Mission: none; 1 or 2 days in game
Third Location: "Gaptooth Ridge"
-------
Required Mission: none; 1 or 2 days in game
Fourth Location: "Tumbleweed"
18. Funny Man
Required Mission: "Exhuming and Other fine hobbies"
First Location: "Benedict Point"
-------
Required Mission: "Man is born Unto Trouble"
Second Location: "Gaptooth Breech"
-------
Required Mission: "Man is born Unto Trouble"
Third Location: "Pike's Basin"
-------
Required Mission: "Empty Promises"
Fourth Location: "Tesoro Azul"
19. American Appetites
Required Mission: "Political Realities in Armadillo"
First Location: "Armadillo"
-------
Required Mission: "Justice in Pike's Basin"
Second Location: "Armadillo"
-------
Required Mission: "Wild Horses Tamed Passions"
Third Location: "Armadillo" |
Stranger Map
Buckin' Awesome
Break the Kentucky Saddler, the American Standardbred, and the Hungarian Half-bred.
The only hard part about this trophy is finding the horses. The horses are always in the same general area but they made sometimes be hard to see or not even out at all depending on the time of day. If you look on your map there will also be a horse icon around the same area. If you ride around the following aread however you will eventually see the horses.
Kentucky Saddler - McFarlane's Ranch in New Austin. The horse is a brown, black, or chestnut, often with white face and leg markings.
American Standerdbred - Beecher's Hope in West Elizabeth. The horse is all black so I suggest you avoid trying to find it at night.
Hungarian Half-Bred - Between Escalera and Punta Orugullo in Mexico. The horse is all white except for its face which is black.
Clemency Pays
Capture a bounty alive.
Before you attempt to get this trophy you will need two things. The ability to capture bounties and a lasso. You will get the ability to capture bounties after the mission "Political Realities in Armadillo." You will unlock the lasso after the mission "Wild Horses, Tamed Passions." With these two requirements met you will be ready to get this trophy.
In every major town and some small settlements you will find bounties. These are represented by the skull on your mini map. Go to the marker and read the wanted poster. Once you accept the bounty red markers will appear on your map that will take you directly to the criminal you are trying to capture. I suggest you shoot the bounties fellow outlaws first to make it easier on yourself. Now it should be you, your horse and the target. You can either shoot the target in the leg to stun him while you hogtie him or you could simply lasso him. To hogtie him get near him when he's either on the ground or he's already in your lasso and push
. Once he's hogtied pick him up and place him on the back of your horse. Then ride to the nearest jail and put him behind bars. Your trophy will appear soon after. Below is a video of what it should look like. Thanks
leadexample for the video.